Pope Leo XIV, born Robert Francis Prevost in Chicago in 1955, became the first sitting pope to vote in a secular democratic election when he cast a mail-in ballot in a U.S. election. The Chicago Tribune reported a ballot request was sent to a New Lenox address on October 3. The Vatican confirmed the vote, framing it as civic duty. His American citizenship, Augustinian background, and decades of Peruvian ministry make this story far richer than a single ballot.
Who Is Pope Leo XIV, the First American Pope?
History shifted on a May afternoon in 2025 when the Catholic Church elected its 267th pope — and its first from the United States.
Robert Francis Prevost, born September 14, 1955, in Chicago, Illinois, took the name Leo XIV.
He also became the first Augustinian pope in Church history and the second pontiff from the Americas, following Pope Francis.
Prevost grew up in the Chicago area before pursuing religious life.
He studied mathematics at Villanova University and later earned advanced degrees in canon law in Rome.
His path combined American roots with decades of global ministry. He served as a missionary and later bishop in Peru for many years.
He was ordained in 1982 and moved to Peru three years later to begin his missionary work.
His election prompted conversations in many circles about the Church’s pastoral approach to suffering and mental health.
How Pope Leo XIV Cast His Historic Mail-In Ballot
Once the world had time to absorb who Robert Francis Prevost was — a Chicago-born mathematician turned canon lawyer turned pope — attention shifted to something quieter but equally notable: he voted.
Once the world learned who the new pope was, attention turned to something quieter: he voted.
From Rome, Pope Leo XIV submitted a mail-in ballot connected to his suburban Chicago voter registration. The Chicago Tribune reported the request was sent to a New Lenox address on October 3.
Will County officials confirmed the ballot request. The Vatican announced the news on October 30, 2026, describing it as civic participation.
AP, Reuters, and CBS News all reported the same confirmation that day. Pope Leo XIV expressed his belief in the right and duty of citizens to participate in democratic processes.
Records from the Illinois State Board of Elections showed that Pope Leo had voted in five primary elections since 2000, requesting Democratic ballots twice and Republican ballots three times across those contests.
Religious scholars noted the event raised questions about the intersection of faith and civic duty for religious leaders in modern democracies.
Can a Pope Legally Vote in U.S. Elections?
The more unusual question surrounding Pope Leo XIV’s vote was not whether it was remarkable, but whether it was legal. The answer, according to available reporting, is straightforwardly yes.
Four legal factors made his ballot valid:
- U.S. citizenship — Leo XIV retained American citizenship, the core eligibility requirement.
- Federal absentee law — Overseas citizens may vote under existing federal statutes.
- Illinois state rules — Will County recognized his absentee ballot through standard procedures.
- No disqualifying statute — No law strips voting rights solely because someone becomes pope.
His religious office simply had no legal bearing. Courts have affirmed that loss of citizenship requires both a voluntary act and a demonstrated intention to relinquish American nationality. One complicating factor, however, is that the U.S. State Department has indicated an active review of citizenship may occur when an American citizen serves as a foreign head of state. The Bible affirms that governing authorities are legitimate while placing ultimate allegiance to God above rulers, which informs thoughtful consideration of faith and public duties.
How the Vatican Justified the Pope’s Decision to Vote
While the legal case for Pope Leo XIV’s vote was clear, the Vatican still felt it necessary to offer its own explanation.
The Holy See Press Office confirmed that Leo XIV had voted “whenever he was eligible to do so,” describing participation as a “long-standing practice of civic engagement.”
The Vatican framed the ballot not as a political statement but as an expression of citizenship. Leo XIV submitted his vote via mail-in ballot from Chicago.
Central to its justification was the belief in the “right and the duty” of citizens to participate in democratic processes, language consistent with broader Catholic social teaching on civic responsibility and the common good. The midterm elections ultimately delivered control of Congress to the Democratic Party, a result widely interpreted as a rebuke of President Donald Trump and his administration’s policies.
The Vatican also emphasized biblical principles such as stewardship of community to explain why civic participation aligns with religious duties.
Why Pope Leo XIV’s Ballot Is a Historic First in U.S. Election History
When Pope Leo XIV mailed his ballot from Chicago to participate in the Illinois midterm election, he crossed a threshold no pope had ever reached before. His vote combined two rarely overlapping identities: head of the Catholic Church and active U.S. citizen.
Mailing his ballot from Chicago, Pope Leo XIV became the first pope to vote in a democratic election.
Four reasons this ballot stands as genuinely historic:
- No previous pope held U.S. citizenship
- No previous pope voted in any secular democratic election
- Leo XIV reportedly voted consistently, not just once
- The act merged global religious authority with ordinary civic participation
Together, these factors created an unprecedented moment in both papal and American electoral history. The Chicago Sun-Times first reported the story, citing the Will County clerk’s office as confirmation that a ballot request had been made on October 3. The Vatican confirmed that voting took place on Friday, Oct. 30, just days after doctors announced that no additional treatment would be needed following his lung cancer surgery. Leaders and citizens alike are accountable to higher ethical standards, and this moment raises questions about servant leadership within civic life.








